The American Hotel

Early Supper


December 31, 2023



Dover Sole Broth

Warm Sorrel Soup

Bison Carpaccio

Oysters Romanoff

Pate de Foie de Canard au Truffé


Mixed Baby Lettuces with Artichoke Hearts

Caesar Salad


Montauk Black Fish à la Bonne Femme

Wild Norwegian Salmon Sauce Hollandaise

Roast Long Island Duck Breast a la Montmorency

Gigot d’Agneau Leg of Lamb Herbes de Provence

Tournedos Rossini

Risotto a la Primavera

Lobster Newburg


Holiday Dessert Selection


$125 Adults / $85 Children 12 & Under 


Littleneck Clams (8) $22 Peconic Oysters (8) $32

Clams per dozen $28  Oysters per dozen $42

Jumbo (5) Shrimp Cocktail $30

American Hackleback Caviar $90 Oscetra $150 Beluga Hybrid Kaluga $200

Sirloin Steak Maître d’hôtel $15 Supplement

Grilled or Steamed Lobster $20 supplement


*These menu items are served raw or are cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked food may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server if anyone in your party has a food allergy. We are not able to accommodate all food allergies and dietary restrictions. SUIFFOLK COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH